[Experiment] Pain Endurance Expression Prompts — How Far Can Subtle Expression Control Go?

[Experiment] Pain Endurance Expression Prompts — How Far Can Subtle Expression Control Go?

Conclusion

  • Even simple 1-2 word expressions reliably produce expression changes (pained expression, gritting teeth, tearful, etc.)
  • Detailed descriptions (H–L) achieve higher expression intensity and consistency than simple expressions
  • “biting lip” tends toward a sensual nuance rather than pain — a detailed description (K) is needed to convey a pain context
  • Expression intensity scale: calm (A) → worried (B) → gritting teeth (C/H) → crying (G/J) → screaming (L)
  • Even in CFG=1.0, detailed descriptions containing weight syntax show differences in expression intensity

What This Article Covers

  • Effectiveness of pain/agony expression prompts
  • Differences between simple (1-2 word) and detailed (multi-token) expressions
  • What kind of expression each phrase produces
  • Whether subtle expression nuances can be controlled through prompts

Experimental Conditions

ItemValue
Modelz-image-turbo (6B, photorealistic distilled model)
Steps8
Samplereuler
Schedulerddim_uniform
CFG1.0
Image size1024×1024
Seeds42, 123, 789 (3 fixed seeds)

Base Prompt

Base Prompt
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, {EXPRESSION}, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Upper body with soft lighting for consistent focus on expression changes.

Experiment 1: Simple Expression Prompts (1-2 Words)

First checking how much expression can change with minimal tokens.

Condition A: Baseline — No Expression Specified

Condition A
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition A: baseline, no expression Condition A: baseline, no expression Condition A: baseline, no expression

Observations

Calm neutral expression to slight smile. Soft lighting portrait.

Condition B: pained expression (2 tokens)

General expression of pain.

Condition B
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, pained expression, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition B: pained expression Condition B: pained expression Condition B: pained expression

Observations

Furrowed brows with slightly open mouth in a worried/anguished expression. Clear difference from baseline.

Condition C: gritting teeth (2 tokens)

Expression of clenching teeth.

Condition C
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, gritting teeth, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition C: gritting teeth Condition C: gritting teeth Condition C: gritting teeth

Observations

Teeth-clenching expression. Closed mouth with visible effort.

Condition D: biting lip (2 tokens)

Lip-biting expression.

Condition D
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, biting lip, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition D: biting lip Condition D: biting lip Condition D: biting lip

Observations

Lip-biting / finger-to-lips pose. Tends toward sensual/anxious nuance rather than pain.

Condition E: wincing (1 token)

Grimacing expression — instant pain reaction.

Condition E
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, wincing, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition E: wincing Condition E: wincing Condition E: wincing

Observations

Momentary grimace of pain. Eyes slightly narrowed, frown lines between brows.

Condition F: grimacing (1 token)

Anguished expression.

Condition F
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, grimacing, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition F: grimacing Condition F: grimacing Condition F: grimacing

Observations

Anguished expression. Deeper frown lines than E, mouth corners dropping, overall facial muscle tension stronger.

Condition G: tearful expression (2 tokens)

Expression on the verge of tears.

Condition G
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, tearful expression, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition G: tearful expression Condition G: tearful expression Condition G: tearful expression

Observations

Holding-back-tears expression. Eyes filling with tears.

Experiment 2: Detailed Expression Descriptions (Multi-Token)

Testing the effect of detailed multi-token pain expression descriptions. The focus is on how much accuracy improves compared to simple expressions.

Condition H: Intense Pain Endurance — Gritting Type

Wide horizontal mouth open, upper and lower teeth showing and clenched.

Condition H
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, (closed eyes:1.4), (eyes squeezed shut:1.3), (lips retracted showing all teeth:1.4), (teeth clenched together:1.3), (downturned mouth corners:1.4), (grimace of agony:1.3), lower teeth and upper teeth fully visible, mouth wide horizontally, nose scrunched, facial muscles strained, neck tendons, sweat, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition H: detailed gritting type Condition H: detailed gritting type Condition H: detailed gritting type

Observations

Eyes closed, teeth clenched, neck tendons taut — intense pain expression. Higher intensity than simple expression (C: gritting teeth).

Condition I: Intense Pain Endurance — Frozen Type

Frozen expression with wide-open eyes.

Condition I
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, (eyes wide open:1.5), (staring:1.3), (mouth slightly open:1.2), (throat seized:1.3), (unable to breathe:1.2), paralyzed by pain, pupils tiny, sclera visible, eyebrows raised, jaw tense, neck tendons straining, veins visible, sweat, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition I: detailed frozen type Condition I: detailed frozen type Condition I: detailed frozen type

Observations

Frozen expression with wide-open eyes and slightly parted mouth. Close to an expression of fear.

Condition J: Intense Pain Endurance — Crying Type

Crying while enduring pain.

Condition J
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, (crying in pain:1.4), (sobbing:1.3), (tears streaming:1.3), (open mouth showing teeth:1.3), (eyes half open:1.2), face contorted in anguish, brows raised high, chin quivering, messy wet face, sweat, upper body, looking at viewer, indoor, soft lighting

Condition J: detailed crying type Condition J: detailed crying type Condition J: detailed crying type

Observations

Open-mouthed crying with tears streaming. Facial muscle tension depicted.

Condition K: Intense Pain Endurance — Stoic Endurance Type

Quietly enduring pain with bitten lip and downcast eyes.

Condition K
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, (biting_lip:1.6), (lip_bite:1.5), looking down with half closed eyes, pained expression, tears in eyes, furrowed brows, sweat, enduring, upper body, indoor, soft lighting

Condition K: detailed stoic endurance Condition K: detailed stoic endurance Condition K: detailed stoic endurance

Observations

Downcast eyes, bitten lip, tears and sweat — a quietly enduring expression. Clearly more pain context than simple “biting lip” (D).

Condition L: Screaming Extreme Pain Type

Extreme pain expression screaming with wide-open eyes.

Condition L
1girl, 32yo japanese actress, (extreme agony:1.2), screaming, mouth wide open, (eyes forced wide open:1.3), (sclera fully visible:1.3), sclera above and below iris, full eyeballs visible, pupils trembling, brows furrowed, face tensed, veins visible, face red, neck tendons, tears, sweat, upper body, indoor, soft lighting

Condition L: screaming extreme pain Condition L: screaming extreme pain Condition L: screaming extreme pain

Observations

Mouth wide open screaming. Sweat and tears across the face, flushed skin. The most intense expression of all conditions.

Cross-Comparison

Simple Expression Comparison (baseline / pained / gritting / biting lip / wincing / grimacing / tearful)

SeedBaseline (A)pained (B)gritting (C)biting lip (D)wincing (E)grimacing (F)tearful (G)
42Baselinepainedgrittingbiting lipwincinggrimacingtearful
123Baselinepainedgrittingbiting lipwincinggrimacingtearful
789Baselinepainedgrittingbiting lipwincinggrimacingtearful

Expression changes are clear even with 1-2 words. Only biting lip tends toward sensual rather than pain nuance.

Simple vs Detailed Description Comparison

Seedgritting teeth (C)detailed gritting (H)biting lip (D)detailed stoic (K)tearful (G)detailed crying (J)
42gritting teethdetailed grittingbiting lipdetailed stoictearfuldetailed crying
123gritting teethdetailed grittingbiting lipdetailed stoictearfuldetailed crying
789gritting teethdetailed grittingbiting lipdetailed stoictearfuldetailed crying

Detailed descriptions produce higher expression intensity and consistency than simple expressions.

Key Findings

Effectiveness of Simple Expressions

  • Expression changes are reliably produced even with 1-2 words. pained expression, gritting teeth, tearful expression etc. show clear differences from baseline
  • However, “intensity” and “consistency” of expression is inferior to detailed descriptions

Superiority of Detailed Descriptions

  • Detailed descriptions (H–L) achieve higher expression intensity than simple expressions, with improved consistency across 3 images
  • Weight syntax (1.3–1.6) influences expression direction even in CFG=1.0 environment

Characteristics by Expression

  • pained expression: General anguished expression. Direction is stable
  • gritting teeth: Specialized for teeth-clenching. Mouth depiction is clear
  • biting lip: Tends toward sensual/anxious nuance rather than pain. Use detailed description (K) if pain context is needed
  • wincing: Momentary reaction. Concentrated on eyes and brow area
  • grimacing: More sustained discomfort than wincing
  • tearful expression: Specialized for tear depiction

Expression Intensity Scale

Calm (A) → worried/anguished (B) → gritting teeth (C/H) → grimacing (E/F) → crying (G/J) → stoic endurance (K) → screaming (L)